Separation Leads to Holiness
Holiness is something to which the world is
gradually becoming opened after a long period of mayhem in the wake of the
‘enlightenment.’ People have long mistaken spirituality for holiness, and the
world is replete with spirituality, which is not necessarily holy. It is
possible to be involved in all kinds of spiritualism that actually draws energy
from what we call ‘the other side’ – the side of impurity. Voodoo, seances,
divinations and tarot cards etc. are examples of such spirituality prohibited
in the Torah from the mitzvah, “You shall be pure with Hashem Your G-d” (Devarim
18:13). The first time you find the root ק-ד-ש/kuf-dalet-shin
– ‘holy’ in the Torah is
ספר בראשית פרק ב פסוק ג וַיְבָרֶךְ אֱלֹהִים אֶת יוֹם הַשְּׁבִיעִי
וַיְקַדֵּשׁ אֹתוֹ...
“G-d blessed the seventh day and sanctified (ק-ד-ש) it…” (Bereishit 2:3).
Shabbat is the quintessence of holiness. We
initiate the holiness of Shabbat into our homes by making kiddush
(sanctification). Kiddush on Shabbat denotes that Shabbat is separated from the
weekdays. It is separated and elevated above the mundane week, through Hashem’s
completing the Creation and resting. Therefore, On Shabbat we emulate Hashem by
resting from creative works. This teaches us that holiness is about separation.
Separation leads to holiness and holiness is separateness and elevation. Due to
the Corona pandemic, with its social distancing, we are being opened to
understand the importance of separation. The Talmud states, “Torah leads to
Watchfulness; Watchfulness leads to Zeal; Zeal leads to Cleanliness;
Cleanliness leads to Separation; Separation leads to Purity; Purity leads to
Saintliness; Saintliness leads to Humility; Humility leads to Fear of Sin; Fear
of Sin leads to Holiness…” (Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 20b). The
famous book, “The Path of the Just” by Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto shares
practical teachings for how to attain these steps of character perfection and
reach the level of kedusha – holiness. Lately, we have been compelled to
become zealous about separation, and purity, as we have been sanitizing
doorknobs and plastic wrapping in order to separate and protect ourselves from
the invasive virus. This ingrains within us the awareness of separation on a
physical, emotional, social and spiritual level. It also propels us closer to
attaining the level of holiness. We may ask ourselves, “what is the essence of
life, and the most important existential values? What do I want to hang on to
and what do I want to separate from my life?”
Must Men and Women Sit Separately at
a Wedding?
A while ago an alumna student who was getting
married consulted with me regarding separate seating at her wedding. She asked,
“My chatan (groom) wants separate seating. I’m
interested to know whether this is a chumra (stringency) or halacha
(Jewish law)? I understand that of course women’s dancing must be separate and
screened off from the eyes of the men, but what about the seating? I feel weird
about splitting up families, but I think this is what we will be doing as it is
the norm in my chatan’s community. Let me know your thoughts!”
The following is my response to her: “The more
kedusha the better, when you marry, you need to follow your husband’s halacha
and minhag. Therefore, I would go with the halacha/minhag of your husband- to-
be. Furthermore, separate seating is a
good way to start a holy marriage, by increasing kedusha. There are even
halachic sources that state that at a wedding where men and women sit together,
we don’t recite the special wedding blessing שֶׁהַשִּׂמְחָה בִּמְעוֹנוֹ/she hasimcha b’meono – ‘that the happiness is in our
abode’ prior to the Grace after Meals, because there is no happiness when the yetzer
hara (negative impulse) rules (Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 149:1).
However, more modern commentaries note that we do not keep this stringency
today, since nowadays it is customary that men and women mingle. Since men are
now used to seeing women, there is less risk that it will cause them impure
thoughts of sin (Levush haChor, Likutei Minhagim 36). Nevertheless,
Rashi on Parashat Kedoshim teaches that wherever you find a separation
fence against inappropriate sexuality, you find kedusha – holiness:
רש"י על ויקרא פרק יט פסוק ב
דבר אל כל עדת בני ישראל - (ויקרא רבה. ת"כ) מלמד שנאמרה פרשה זו
בהקהל מפני שרוב גופי תורה תלוין בה: קדושים תהיו - הוו פרושים מן העריות ומן העבירה (ויקרא רבה) שכל
מקום שאתה מוצא גדר ערוה אתה מוצא קדושה (ויקרא כא) אשה זונה וחללה וגו' אני ה'
מקדשכם. (שם) ולא יחלל זרעו - אני ה' מקדשו. (שם) קדושים יהיו - אשה זונה וחללה
וגו':
You shall be holy: Separate yourselves from sexual
immorality and from sin, for wherever one finds a barrier against sexual
immorality, one finds holiness. [for example, the Kohanim] “shall be holy to
their G-d… they shall not marry a woman who engaged in forbidden sexual
relations or one who was profaned…I, Hashem, Who sanctifies you [am holy]”… (Vayikra
21:6-8); (Rashi, Vayikra 19:2).
If separate seating would really make some family
members uncomfortable, I would make a special, small, mixed family section for
them. At my son’s wedding, we had three sections: one for men, another for
women, and a third for the family members who would feel uncomfortable if men
and women would have to be separated. There are accepted halachic authorities
who permit mixed seating at a wedding (Igrot Moshe, Orach Chaim 1:41),
however, this only pertains to assigned seats, where families sit together, but
not to situations like receptions and buffets where people walk around and
intermingle (Ibid. 39).
The Redemptive Points of Corona
Bringing Us Closer to Kedusha
It is interesting to note that the Jewish marriage
ceremony is called kedushin (holiness) because it separates the wife
from being available to other men, while dedicating her to her husband alone.
When husband and wife guard the sanctity of marriage, by keeping a fence from
others of the opposite sex, they sanctify their holy marriage unit. Limiting
contact between unrelated men and women precludes them from inadvertently
experiencing natural attraction and prevents flirting and more... Despite the
hardship of the Corona epidemic, it has brought us closer to kedusha and served
as a great fence against sexual immorality. When the bars and discotheques are
closed and there is a curfew for leaving our homes, incurring monetary fines,
people are forced to stay within the family unit. I know a couple that have
been living in a paperless marriage for years, who are now required to remain
separate as they each have their own apartment. Had they been married with a
Chuppah and Kedushin, and moved in together they would have been able to remain
together. Due to the epidemic, the opportunities for men and women to date is
limited and certainly any physical contact between them is barred, by the
requirement to keep two meters apart. The world is certainly experiencing a
great upheaval. While our planet is being devastated by illness and panic, from
within the hardships peek redemptive points. People are talking about how the
Corona virus has reduced pollution in the world greatly. The choking smog of
major cities in China – caused by the extensive burning of coal by factories –
has been greatly diminished. On
Feb. 20, daily coal consumption of six major power plants was 42.5% less than
the same period last year. Although it can’t be measured as easily, I will
venture to say that Corona has reduced not only the physical but also the
spiritual pollution of immoral sexual behavior outside the sanctity of
marriage. We are certainly living in redemptive times as portrayed by the
prophet, “…the spirit of contamination I will remove from the earth” (Zechariah
13:2).
the points you brought up are very interesting-I have not seen anybody else discussing the connection between social distancing & an increase of holiness in this world but of course you are right!We are learning what are "healthy" or "unhealthy" physical contacts- those within a relationship of holiness are, all the others are not. Well, almost -some couples living together in unmarried or same-gender relationships can still interact, despite the restrictions, but the entire world is certainly being taught important lessons!
ReplyDeleteThis is a wonderful essay, revealing the deep aspects and available benefits of our isolating in our family units, thanks so much!
ReplyDelete