Are there Kosher Torah Ways of ‘Curse Removal’?

 

Parashat Emor

Make the Utmost Effort to Avoid Inadvertently Cursing Anyone 
I am blessed that I have almost never been cursed. I also don’t recall ever being privy to someone cursing anyone else. Sadly, the only example I recall of hearing a person curse was our Hebrew teacher in the Jewish elementary school. Since we, students, were very unruly and did everything in our power to disrupt the class, the teacher naturally became very frustrated. He would often let out an outburst of a stream of curses. This happened almost in every class- and not only when a thumbtack was placed on his seat. I still, to this day – half a century afterward, recall the words coming out of his mouth: “I’m going to dance on your grave!” yelled in a heavy Swedish accent. I have only compassion for this teacher, may his soul be elevated! He was unaware that although I don’t remember anything from his formal classes, he actually taught me a great deal about the importance of refinement of speech and by all means avoiding curses – the worst kind of negative speech. Since Hashem created the world with speech, words are powerful, and have an effect upon ourselves, on our environment, and upon other people. When Ya’acov said to Lavan, “…whoever has your gods shall die” (Bereishit 30:32) his words inadvertently caused Rachel’s untimely death. Therefore, I always try to be careful with the use of my words and I won’t let anyone say even unmeaningly something like, “If you don’t sleep enough, you will get sick, etc.” I always correct people to say, “if somebody doesn’t sleep enough, he will get sick,” and the like. I believe that it is important to avoid using any negative term to refer to the person we speak with, even if using it as an example. A tzaddik decrees and it becomes established, as it states, “You will decree, and it will be established for you, and light will shine on all your ways” (Iyuv 22:28; Yalkut Shimoni, Shemot 2:165). Since we don’t know for sure that we are not a tzaddik, it is of utmost importance to accustom ourselves to continually bring words of blessings to our lips. 

What are Some Segulot (Spiritual Remedies) to Overcome a Possible Curse? 
In my practice as a spiritual healer, clients occasionally come to me because they feel they may have been cursed since everything in their lives just seems to go wrong. They, therefore, ask me to reverse the curse and its effects. First of all, I calm my clients by explaining that the power of good always outdoes the power of evil. When you are connected to Hashem and keep the Torah and mitzvot, you are spiritually protected. Mostly, it is the fear that lowers a person’s vibration to be susceptible to negative energy from others. So, strengthening our emunah is the first step of taharat klalot (curse purification or removal). The Lubavitcher Rebbe, of blessed memory, held that, nowadays, there is no reason to be concerned about curses. In order to draw down Hashem’s blessings, and to counteract negative judgment, G-d forbid, we must strengthen our Torah and mitzvah observance. A powerful spiritual remedy, especially for women, is to be careful to light the Shabbat candles in time (18 minutes before sunset)! Also, make sure to look at the candles again after dark. Another important spiritual protection is to check your mezuzot at least twice in seven years (Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah 291:1). Some people are even more strict and have their mezuzot checked every year (Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef, Yehaveh Da’at, Vol. 1, No. 49). If everything seems to be going wrong in somebody’s life (note I didn’t write “in our lives”), it's recommended to have the mezuzot checked if more than a year has passed since they were last checked. 

How does Parashat Emor Center Around Speech?
Parashat Emor means “Speak.” Both the beginning and the end of the parasha centers around ‘speech.’ It opens by commanding Moshe to speak to the Kohanim and tell them not to allow themselves to become impure by contact with the dead, except for close relatives (Vayikra 21:1-2). It continues by warning us against blasphemy which is also through speech, “You shall not desecrate My Holy Name… (Vayikra 22:32). Even the middle of the parasha, about the Jewish holidays, is connected to speech since they are called מִקְרָאֵ֣י קֹ֑דֶשׁ/Mikrei Kodesh meaning “they are called or pronounced holy” (Vayikra Chapter 23). The end of the Parasha describes the man who employed the ultimate misuse of speech by cursing G-d:

ספר ויקרא פרק כד פסוק י

וַיֵּצֵא בֶּן אִשָּׁה יִשְׂרְאֵלִית וְהוּא בֶּן אִישׁ מִצְרִי בְּתוֹךְ בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל וַיִּנָּצוּ בַּמַּחֲנֶה בֶּן הַיִּשְׂרְאֵלִית וְאִישׁ הַיִּשְׂרְאֵלִי:                           (יא) וַיִּקֹּב בֶּן הָאִשָּׁה הַיִּשְׂרְאֵלִית אֶת הַשֵּׁם וַיְקַלֵּל  וַיָּבִיאוּ אֹתוֹ אֶל משֶׁה וְשֵׁם אִמּוֹ שְׁלֹמִית בַּת דִּבְרִי לְמַטֵּה דָן

“Now, the son of an Israelite woman and he was the son of an Egyptian man went out among the children of Israel, and they quarreled in the camp this son of the Israelite woman, and an Israelite man. 11 And the son of the Israelite woman pronounced the [Divine] Name and cursed. So, they brought him to Moses. His mother’s name was Shlomit the daughter of Dibri, of the tribe of Dan" (Vayikra 24:10-11). 

Rashi explains that this blasphemer was the son of the Egyptian man, whom Moshe killed using the Divine Name, because he was going to murder a Jew. He came to Moshe complaining that he killed his father by means of the Holy Name. For that reason, “they brought him to Moshe.” When Moshe saw that, immediately, “they put him in custody” (Vayikra 24:12). Both father and son fell into Moshes’ hands (Zohar 3:106a). 

Why does the Torah Only Mention the Name of Blasphemer’s Mother?
The fact that the Torah doesn’t mention the name of the blasphemer, but only that of his mother, teaches us that his mother was instrumental in affecting the nature of her son, to become a person who curses. He learned his misuse of words from his mother. There is a strong bond between mother and child due to the fetus being formed within her and remaining there for the entire period of gestation. Even after birth, the baby receives his main nourishment from her. When a person is righteous, modest and virtuous, it is often a result of his mother’s positive influence. The opposite is unfortunately also true. Although we try not to blame the victim, Rashi explains that Scripture hints, through the meaning of her name, that Shlomit was self-disposed towards being assaulted. The name Shlomit is related to the Hebrew greeting, “Shalom,” and Dibri to the word דַּבֵּר /daber – ‘speech.’ She was called Shlomit bat Dibri because she was always babbling: “how are you?”, “how are you?”, and “how are you?” She was a bat Dibri; talking with any man in the street. This is what eventually caused her to get into trouble (Rashi, Vayikra 24:11). Shlomit bat Dibri, was an extremely attractive woman. One day, an Egyptian taskmaster, in charge of one hundred and twenty Jewish slaves, noticed her, when he went on his usual rounds to the homes of his workers, in order to assemble them. With his eye on Shlomit, he called her husband out to work and returned to her house, pretending to be her husband. When Shlomit’s husband saw the Egyptian man exit his house, he was concerned and asked his wife whether he had touched her. She answered, “Yes, but I thought that he was you.” Once the taskmaster found out that Shlomit’s husband was aware of what had taken place, he whipped him. This was the Egyptian man that Moshe killed. He could see with Ruach HaKodesh that the taskmaster deserved death for committing adultery (Midrash Tanchuma, Shemot 9; Rebbetzin Chana Bracha, Women at the Crossroads pg. 113). 

The Kohanim Blessing as a Powerful Curse Reversal in the Torah
One of the main lessons to take home from Parashat Emor is the importance of avoiding the misuse of speech. Too much chatter can have a very negative ripple effect. In this life, there is blessing and there is curse. We must continually bless our Creator, that He may continue to bless us. In spiritual healing, we recite blessings in order to remove curses. The most powerful blessing in the Torah is Birkat HaKohanim – the Kohanim blessing. With this blessing. parents bless their children Friday night. My teacher, Chana Luke, taught us that to undo a curse, we bless the person with the Birkat Hakohanim: 

 :יְבָרֶכְךָ הָשֵׁם וְיִשְׁמְרֶךָ יָאֵר הָשֵׁם פָּנָיו אֵלֶיךָ וִיחֻנֶּךָּ יִשָּׂא הָשֵׁם פָּנָיו אֵלֶיךָ וְיָשֵׂם לְךָ שָׁלוֹם

“May Hashem bless you and watch over you. May Hashem cause His countenance to shine to you and favor you. May Hashem raise His countenance toward you and grant you peace” (Bamidbar 6:23).

We say it two times and as always, when reciting any blessing and Torah verse, we must say the phrases with the proper intention. Recite the letters and Names in their correct order and with great focus. When pronouncing the holy Names, attempt to become fully aware of the divine spark in all Life. Reciting Torah verses for spiritual healing is no pretense or witchcraft to be dismissed as a superstitious rite. For what is holy is tremendously powerful. Handled with deep reverence and the greatest caution, Hashem will heal and protect us through the Holy words of His Torah. 

How Do We Achieve Healthy Holiness?

Parashat Acharei Mot/Kedoshim

What is the Difference between Spirituality and Holiness?

I always strived for holiness of body and soul. Since I didn’t find it in my native country or in the watered-down Judaism I encountered there, I searched in every other religion and lifestyle I could wrap my mind around, but to no avail. I tried to expand my consciousness to reach higher awareness and holiness through meditation and some of the lighter mind-altering drugs (I was, blessedly, apprehensive to try the hardcore ones). In their search for spirituality, many of my friends adopted an Indian-inspired lifestyle, which included asceticism and seclusion. I instinctively knew that this path was not for me, so I kept searching until I found the Torah in Israel, thank G-d! I connected with the spiritual community of the yeshiva, and with the Torah lifestyle that embraced the good things of this world, through connecting and elevating the physical rather than resorting to ascetism. So, what’s wrong with meditating alone on a mountain? I believe the answer can be found in the difference between spirituality and holiness. The English word ‘spiritual’ is an antonym to ‘physical.’ So, any endeavor that separates from the physical can be considered spiritual. Spirituality, therefore, is not necessarily desirable, as it includes idol-worship, witchcraft, and various kinds of new age spirituality, voodoo, seances, connecting with the spirits of the dead, summoning negative spirits, and more. There are many evil people who are spiritual, including those described in the Bible, from Bilam to Haman. Actually, the very last verse of our parasha warns us against this kind of spirituality: “A man or a woman who practices [the sorcery of] Ov or Yid’oni, shall surely be put to death; they shall pelt them with stones; their blood is upon themselves” (Vayikra 20:27). A ba’al ov literally means ‘master of spirits.’ Holiness, on the other hand, is to follow Hashem and His Torah to the T. Thus, the difference between the sin of the Golden Calf and the mitzvah of constructing the Tabernacle with the Golden cherubs, simply boils down to whether or not Hashem has commanded it. Holiness supersedes spirituality, as the highest holiness takes place specifically through interacting within the physical realm. For example, drinking wine and enjoying meat on Shabbat can be very holy. The word ‘קִדּוּשׁ/kiddush’ which we make on wine, at the onset of Shabbat and holidays, is another form of the word קָדוֹשׁ/kadosh which means ‘holy.’ No wonder, that it was the holiness I sensed on Shabbat at the Yeshiva, that first attracted me to Torah. 

What Is Wrong with the Pathway of Aharon’s Sons? 
For a Jew to be healthy is to be holy. This is because our spiritual health is no less important than physical health. The two parashot Acharei Mot and Kedoshim are often read together. Perhaps, it is for the sake of comparing them via contrast. Acharei Mot refers to the death of two of Aharon’s sons, Nadav and Avihu, who sacrificed a strange fire in the previous parasha. Now, in this week’s parasha, Hashem warns us not to follow their example, as it states, “Hashem spoke to Moshe after the death of Aharon’s two sons, when they drew near before Hashem, and they died… Speak to your brother Aharon, that he should not come at all times into the Holy within the dividing curtain, in front of the cover that is upon the ark, so that he should not die…” (Vayikra 16:1). Throughout the generations, many people claimed themselves to be ‘holy’ by walking in the footsteps of Nadav and Avihu. In fact, I know people today who believe that following this path makes them holy. What, exactly, was wrong with the way of Aharon’s sons, and what is so alluring about their path for certain people? The Torah says that they brought a foreign fire before Hashem, which He had not commanded them (Vayikra 10:1). This is clear support for the differentiation we made between spirituality and holiness. Aharon’s sons were clearly on a very high spiritual level. They wanted to reach the highest level of consciousness and closeness to the Divine through their sacrifice. Yet, despite their lofty, passionate intentions, their fire-offering was considered “strange” and the cause of their death due to it being a fire “which He had not commanded them.” The deed of Aharon’s sons, referred to at the beginning of Parashat Acharei Mot, is contrasted with the holiness described in the second of the double parshiot, Parashat Kedoshim – “You shall be holy!”

Holiness Requires Attaching Oneself to the Community
The Torah commentaries are puzzled by the unusual opening expression of Parashat Kedoshim, “Speak to the entire congregation of the children of Israel…” which differs from any other opening verse describing Hashem’s command to the Jewish people: 

:ספר ויקרא פרק יט פסוק ב דַּבֵּר אֶל כָּל עֲדַת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל וְאָמַרְתָּ אֲלֵהֶם קְדשִׁים תִּהְיוּ כִּי קָדוֹשׁ אֲנִי הָשֵׁם אֱלֹהֵיכֶם

“Speak to the entire congregation of the children of Israel, and say to them, You shall be holy, for I, Hashem, your G-d, am holy” (Vayikra 19:2).

When it comes to the recipe for holiness, it must be taught to a congregation at large, for an individual can only be holy by attaching him or herself to the community. In order to avoid evil, a person sometimes needs to escape the company of others (Rambam Hilchot Deot 6:1). Yet, this approach will not bring a Jew to holiness. To reach holiness, we need to join the community when serving Hashem, both in Torah learning, in prayer, and in good deeds. It is impossible to reach holiness without being united as a congregation. Parashat Kedoshim, which teaches us to become holy, relates equally to Jews of various social statuses and backgrounds: To the Kohen, the judge, the son, the farmer, the builder, etc. The complete fulfillment of the Torah depends upon all the different categories of Jews. Therefore, this section was said in assembly, because only the nation as a whole will be able to carry it into action (Meor VaShemesh). To achieve holiness, rather than meditating in solitude on the mountain, secluded from the community of Israel, we must be involved in practical and interpersonal mitzvot as described in Parashat Kedoshim. This parasha includes mitzvot such as expressing awe to our parents, honoring the Shabbat, leaving the corner of the fields for the poor, avoiding stealing and taking advantage of our fellow Jews, planting fruit trees in the holy land, and keeping the laws of the land. 

In Tune with the Natural Rhythm of Running and Returning 
Holiness, according to the Torah, is to live in perfect balance between the spiritual aspiration of running to cleave to G-d on the one hand and being grounded by returning to perform the mitzvot within the physical world on the other. Just as we need to both inhale and exhale, so too do our souls have an internal rhythm of ratzo v’shov – ‘running and returning’ or rushing up and settling down. We learn this Chassidic concept from the following prophetic statement: 

:ספר יחזקאל פרק א פסוק יד וְהַחַיּוֹת רָצוֹא וָשׁוֹב כְּמַרְאֵה הַבָּזָק

“The living creatures ran and returned as the appearance of a flash of lightning” (Yechezkiel 1:14). ¬

Yechezkiel, the prophet, uttered this statement when he saw angels running and returning as part of his vision of the mystical מַעֲשֵׂה מֶרְכָּבָה/Ma’aseh Merkavah – ‘Workings of the Chariot.’ 

Beware of Running without Returning 
Returning to our question of what is so alluring about the path of Aharon’s sons, I know some people who seek spiritual enlightenment by uniting and cleaving in devekut to the Creator through klot hanefesh – allowing the soul to detach from the body in spiritual ecstasy. They often forget the importance of keeping the balance of returning to the body, settling down to do the job of elevating and rectifying this physical world. The Torah warns us that left unchecked, the desire for spiritual ecstasy, ratzo, can lead to the expiration of the soul. The Torah does not advocate expanding our consciousness to achieve spiritual enlightenment for its own sake. Rather, the main way of attaining holiness takes place by serving Hashem within the physical world, elevating this world, and transforming it to a dirah b’tachtonim – a dwelling place for Hashem below. Spiritual excitement is not a goal in itself, but a means to living a balanced life within the body. In order to attain true holy health, one must rectify the physical by taking care of our body through eating drinking and sleeping adequately, for the sake of having the strength to serve Hashem, as well as building and planting in the holy land, and using our G-d-given talents to provide services for the benefit of the world. The momentary ecstasy of the ratzo is meant only to inspire the soul to return to the body, shov – to complete its earthly tasks. Nadav and Avihu were seeking mystical union with Hashem for its own sake, neglecting their ultimate mission of serving G-d in the physical world. They were ratzo – running without shov - returning, leaving their body behind, never to return to the physical world (Inspired by Dr. Alexander Poltorak, Nadab and Abihu — Tragedy in Time. The legacy of Aharon’s sons is to teach us the lesson “not to come at all times into the Holy within the dividing curtain… so that we do not die.” 

We Are What We Speak

Parashat Tazria-Metzora

It is the Torah’s emphasis on morality and ethics – especially the laws of guarding our tongue, that originally attracted me to authentic Judaism. Although I didn’t grow up in a Torah observant home, I hail from an upright family, that emphasizes the importance of living a moral life of honesty and kindness. I recall how my mother would always say when we were kids, “If you don’t have something positive to say, then remain silent!” Even if it took some time for these wise words to seep in, they made a lasting impression and resonated with the essence of my soul. Last week, I wrote about, “You are What you Eat?” Yet, it is an even truer statement to say that “We are what we speak.” Unkelos comments on the Torah verse, “…Adam became a living soul” (Bereishit 2:7), והות באדם לרוח ממללא –“He imbued Adam with a speaking spirit.” Likewise, Rashi highlights that the difference between animals and humans is that “the human soul is the most highly developed of all of them because he was granted understanding and speech.” Our speech reflects who we are more than anything else. When a person engages in negative speech, G-d forbid, he exposes his own negativity. His disparaging words reflect back on himself more than on the subject of his criticism. When he keeps putting other people down, he draws negativity to himself. Therefore, I was saddened by the harshness of many of the comments to my blog on Parashat Vayikra, sharing why I chose to get vaccinated. I was not expecting everyone to agree with me, but judgmental statements such as, “This woman is highly irresponsible…” “She is completely ignorant…” “she should repent…” etc. sadly belong to the category of lashon hara (negative speech), which is not limited to words said behind a person’s back. Conversely, when an offensive word never leaves our lips, it demonstrates our integrity as a refined person. I cannot call myself a saint in this matter. I especially find it hard not to alleviate my heart to my husband about the inappropriate behavior and speech I’ve experienced from others. Yes, I am aware that it is permitted to alleviate our heart to a therapist, mentor, or even a close friend (that would include ‘our significant other’). The problem is to set the boundary when we begin to speak. Rabbi Kessing’s words: “Although you are allowed to vent, who says you can be an air-conditioner?” really hit home! I’d like to share my thoughts on the health benefits of guarding our tongue, why it is so hard to keep this important mitzvah, and tips on how to overcome the pitfalls.  

Why is it so Hard to Guard Our Tongue? 
It is sooooo hard to guard our tongue! The Talmud states, “We all fall prey to a tinge of lashon hara” (Baba Batra 165a). Our evil impulse is always strongest in areas, which are most important and vital for achieving our perfection. Rebbe Nachman explains that all speech is [initially] nice, pleasant, and important – the aspect of Sarah, with whom the Shechina was dwelling. However, it is sometimes snatched by the ‘other side’ or the klipot [husks]. Instead of emerging through the mouth, speech then comes out from the ‘neck’ (and it is possible sometimes to hear that speech does not emerge from the mouth, but rather from the throat/ neck). The klipot always wants to seize speech for themselves and bend it to the wrong means, so they can gain power from our misdeeds. I was thinking about several more tangible reasons for our tendency to speak lashon hara. First of all, since eating from the Tree of Knowledge, the primeval inclination to blame others became part of the inherent human instinctive nature. Adam blamed Chava, and Chava blamed the snake in return. We still carry that inherent shame and guilt-feeling injected by the snake, which we mistakenly believe we can eject from ourselves by blaming someone else. When we feel unworthy and struggle with a lack of self-confidence, putting someone else down, may temporarily give us a false self-image boost. 

Evil Speech May Be an Addiction
Lastly, I believe that lashon hara is addictive. When we are in pain, we may turn to the chocolate bar, the bottle, or to an outburst of negative speech in order to numb ourselves to our personal pain. Negative speech can be a way to suppress or soothe negative emotions, such as stress, anger, fear, boredom, sadness, and loneliness. Yet, if we train ourselves to check in with our inner selves and get in touch with what woes triggered the negative emotions that lead to negative speech, we may be able to prevent it, or at least stop it midway. Even if we already began speaking lashon hara, and we may think that everything is lost, it is not too late to stop- just as when a person begins to eat cookies and thinks that she may as well finish the box. This is not so. For every single additional word that we avoid, an immense light is created, as it states, “Every single moment that a person stops his mouth, he merits the hidden light, that no angel or any creature can even imagine (Chafetz Chayim, Hilchot Lashon Hara 1:7). Meditation, conscious breathing, journaling, forgiveness including self-forgiveness, therapy and more may alleviate the urge to spill out all that poison. 

Using the Paraphrase: “This is for a Beneficial Purpose.”
I can’t recall exactly where I learned that, whenever it is permitted for a constructive purpose to say something disparaging about someone, we must introduce our words with, “I’m saying this for a beneficial purpose.” I used to be really strict about this, but when it is obvious, for example, when I speak with my staff about a problem with a student, the purpose of the conversation is to assist and problem solve, it seems unnecessary, and this paraphrasing went down the drain. However, after teaching Guarding Our Tongue recently, I decided to once again be strict on introducing every word of well-meaning, critical speech with, “This is for a beneficial purpose.” The reason for this is that such a preface will help us to keep our words in check and ensure that we don’t go overboard, saying extra words that are unwarranted to make the necessary points. 

Divine Retribution for Evil Speech
In Parashat Tazria we are introduced to the spiritual disease of tzara’at: 

ספר ויקרא פרק יג פסוק ב אָדָם כִּי יִהְיֶה בְעוֹר בְּשָׂרוֹ שְׂאֵת אוֹ סַפַּחַת אוֹ בַהֶרֶת וְהָיָה בְעוֹר בְּשָׂרוֹ לְנֶגַע צָרָעַת וְהוּבָא אֶל אַהֲרֹן הַכֹּהֵן אוֹ אֶל אַחַד מִבָּנָיו הַכֹּהֲנִים:

“When anyone has a swelling or a rash or a bright spot on his skin that may become an infectious skin disease, he must be brought to Aaron the kohen or to one of his sons, the kohanim” (Vayikra 13:2). The Midrash views tzara’at as an external sign of internal decay. “Israel is only afflicted with plagues due to lashon hara…this is what caused them tzara’at…” (Midrash Vayikra Rabbah 18:4). In Biblical times, when people engaged in evil speech, they would experience direct retribution, becoming infected by tza’ra’at. They would go through a period of isolation and healing, which would be their atonement. Today, we no longer have this spiritual disease. Although speaking lashon hara no longer results in direct physical symptoms, and we don’t get a long nose like Pinocchio, the impurity of derogatory speech still cleaves to a person’s soul, G-d forbid. The effect of the lashon hara, sadly, may need to be expiated in the world-to-come, where the evil speaker may find his soul is infected with tza’ra’at. When the impurity of his soul will be revealed there, he will not be able to enter the palace of Hashem in the Garden of Eden. If he didn’t repent properly, he will need to sit alone outside the camp of Israel, in the place of the klipot in the world above (The Chafetz Chayim, The Gate of Commemoration, Chapter 6, The influence of lashon hara on the Soul). 

No Better Protection from Plagues 
When we guard ourselves against lashon hara, we guard ourselves against the tza’ra’at of our soul, as it states, 

ספר משלי פרק כא ספר משלי פרק כא פסוק כג שֹׁמֵר פִּיו וּלְשׁוֹנוֹ שֹׁמֵרֹ מִצָּרוֹת נַפְשׁוֹ:

“The one who guards his mouth and tongue guards his soul from troubles” (Mishlei 21:23). Thus, becoming more careful with our use of words is advantageous in all ways, and will protect us from plagues and afflictions in this world and grant us eternal life in the next world. The midrash explains that although the men of Shmuel’s generation were great Torah scholars, they would go to war and fall, because there were words of accusation between them. In contrast, although the generation of Achav worshipped idols, when they would go to war, not one of them was killed, because there was no accusation between them (Midrash Tehillim 7). From this, we learn that there is no better way of healing and protection against any plague and ailment than to guard our tongue. May we all merit to eliminate evil speech and gossip and learn to speak only words of wisdom and kindness! May Hashem protect us all from any possible adverse side effects from the pandemic or G-d forbid from the vaccine!

Is Kosher Food Healthier than Non-Kosher Food?

Parashat Shemini

Is it True that “You are What you Eat”? 

I used to be a vegetarian before I embarked on the Torah path. So were my husband and many of our friends. We felt, that not eating un-kosher meat, greatly protected us from its negative effect. Therefore, we were more disposed to embrace the observant Torah way. Conversely, it is possible that those who chose to abstain from devouring meat already were less materialistic types and more spiritually inclined. We wanted our diet to be in line with sustainable living and many of us cared about the way animals were treated. Another concern was how a carnivorous diet exploits global resources and depletes the environment. It was only a natural step up, to go from living caring, moral, environmentally conscious lives, to accept the Divine guidelines for becoming ethical Jews striving to become tzaddikim (righteous) in action, speech, and thought. Learning about the Torah dietary laws, made many of us adapt our vegetarianism to include eating kosher meat in honor of Shabbat. Personally, I try to stay away from eating meat except for organic free-range animals. We are fortunate to have a G-d-fearing ritual slaughterer in Bat Ayin, who provides us with organic, grass-fed beef. As someone who raises chickens, we are aware that taking the life of an animal mustn’t be taken lightly. It can only be justified by eating it mindfully and using its energy to perform Torah and mitzvot. My friends from the past used to say: “You are what you eat!” Let us explore if this dictum holds true according to Torah. 

The Chosen Animals 
Hashem selected the Jewish people for spiritual leadership, for the purpose of elevating the entire world in His service. He, therefore, provided us with the means to achieve our exalted purpose as the chosen people, by giving us the laws of the Torah, including the dietary laws. 

:ספר ויקרא פרק יא  פסוק ב דַּבְּרוּ אֶל בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל לֵאמֹר זֹאת הַחַיָּה אֲשֶׁר תֹּאכְלוּ מִכָּל הַבְּהֵמָה אֲשֶׁר עַל הָאָרֶץ

“Speak to the children of Israel, saying: These are the creatures that you may eat among all the animals on earth” (Vayikra 11:2). 

The word חַיָּה/chaya – ‘living creature’ denotes חַיִּים /chayim – ‘life.’ Since the Israelites cleave to the Omnipresent and are therefore worthy of being alive, accordingly, G-d separates them from impurity and decrees mitzvot upon them [through which they can live] …This is comparable to a physician, who went to visit a patient, who was incurable and allowed him to eat anything he wished. Whereas, when he went to his patient, who was to recover, the physician imposed restrictions on his diet, that would ensure that the recoverable patient would live.…” (Rashi, Vayikra 11:2 based on Midrash Tanchuma). 

Are we Permitted to Ponder the Reasons for Kosher and Non-Kosher Food? 
Parashat Shemini provides us with the criteria for kosher animals and also lists the unkosher beasts, fowl, and fish. The laws of Kashrut (kosher food) belong to the category of Chukim – statutes for which we don’t have logical explanations – and which we must accept simply because Hashem decreed them. Nevertheless, Sefat Emet explains that when we accept to keep the statutes out of pure faith, without demanding to understand their reasons, their reasons will eventually be revealed to us. Everything in the physical world has corresponding spiritual energy that it parallels, symbolizes, or embodies. Ramban notices the difference in nature between kosher and unkosher animals. Namely, milk of kosher animals can curdle, whereas milk of those unfit for food does not coagulate and cannot be made into cheese. Thus, they are physically different. It is possible to say on the basis of this difference that just as their milk is different, so is the meat of unkosher animals different in a way that may harm those who eat them (based on Ramban 11:13).  

Nourishment for the Jewish Soul
The food we consume greatly affects both our physical and spiritual health. Our character and our spiritual sensitivity are greatly influenced by what we eat. Non-kosher foods coarsen the body, and thereby, cloud the holiness of the soul. 

:ספר ויקרא פרק יא פסוק מג אַל תְּשַׁקְּצוּ אֶת נַפְשֹׁתֵיכֶם בְּכָל הַשֶּׁרֶץ הַשֹּׁרֵץ וְלֹא תִטַּמְּאוּ בָּהֶם וְנִטְמֵתֶם בָּם

“You shall not make yourselves abominable with any creeping creature that creeps, and you shall not defile yourselves with them, that you should become impure through them” (Vayikra 11:43).

The first warning וְלֹא תִטַּמְּאוּ/lo titam’u refers to our bodies, whereas the second warning, וְנִטְמֵתֶם/venitamtem refers to our souls. The word וְנִטְמֵתֶם is written without the letter א/alef after the letter מ/mem. The missing א/alef indicates that anyone eating these creatures becomes מטומטם/metumtam – ‘dull-witted’ as a result. Man’s heart becomes ‘encrusted’ through the ingestion of such forbidden creatures so that it can no longer access the Holy Spirit (Rabbeinu Bachaya, Vayikra 11:43). 

Therefore, the Torah warns us against forbidden foods, upon which dwells extraneous impure energy. A person who eats unkosher food makes his soul impure, distances himself from kedusha (holiness), and weakens his connection with the G-d of Israel. Conversely, eating kosher foods, with holy intention causes the attachment of a holy pure spirit so that the soul will enjoy and benefit from the food as it states, “A tzaddik eats to satisfy his soul” (Mishlei 13:25). The holiness of the food thus affects our soul positively (HaShelah HaKodesh, The Gate of the Letters, the Holiness of Eating 1). 

The Cruel Nature of Unkosher Birds
Many Torah commentators draw parallels between the character of animals and their kosher status. All kosher livestock are not beasts of prey, while the rest devour others. Likewise, the list of forbidden birds includes all the predatory birds. These birds are unkosher due to their cruel nature (Ramban, Vayikra 11:13). Any bird which attacks with its claws is automatically known as an impure bird. Our sages (BT, Chulin 62) mention that the reason the Torah forbade the consumption of such birds is that they are more hot-blooded. Their blood turning black indicates a cruel streak in the character of the bird. Eating such a bird leaves a residue of the character of the animal in the person who consumes it. The objectionable part of such a predator bird is that it hunts live prey and does not kill it before feasting on it. Apparently, hawks operate in this manner (Rabbeinu Bachaya, Vayikra 11:13). 

Physical and Spiritual Impact of Kosher Fish 
I’m fortunate that since early childhood, my parents discovered that I was allergic to shellfish, so I was safeguarded from eating prawns, lobsters, oysters, and other sea creatures, which lack the two kosher signs: fins and scales. These two characteristics of kosher fish have both physical and symbolic impacts. Ramban explains that fish, who have the kosher distinguishing features, make their habitat in the upper part of seas or rivers. The waters there are clear and absorb a certain amount of daylight and sunshine. This influences their growth and development. The scales are for fish what hair and wool are for mammals, helping them retain warmth. Fish that lack these features make their habitat in lower layers of the water and so are exposed to the darkness and the murkiness of the waters prevailing there. (Ramban, Vayikra 11:9). Symbolically, the fins with which fish navigate reminds us to navigate through the wisdom of the Torah. The scales are the coat for protection is given to all of those that carry out the mitzvot (Ma’amurei Admur Hazaken, Inyaninim, pg. 130).

Predatory Animals are not Fit Food for the Jewish Nature
Perhaps, we may say that the two signs of a kosher beast teach us to become more mindful and connected to the spiritual dimension. To chew the cud teaches us not to act instinctively on impulse, but to think carefully before blurting out or acting in haste, taking into consideration the consequences of our words and actions. Split hooves, with which the animal connects to the ground, teach us that although we need to interact with the material world, we still maintain a conscious separation (Mordechai Wollenberg, You Are What you Eat). Mild-mannered, submissive, good-natured, kosher cows, deer, and sheep are naturally timid, modest, non-predatory, and quiet animals. Since kosher animals all possess these desirable character traits, this indicates that the Torah concurs with the dictum,  “you are what you eat!”

Pesach and Renewing our Belief in Miracles

The Challenge of Believing in Miracles when Life gets Tough

Pesach is in the air while the dust is dancing to the rhythm of our heavy-duty carpet beater. As we clean and scrub, we must not forget to renew our belief in miracles. Even if we surely believe in G*d and in His Holy Torah, it can be difficult to integrate this belief into our personal lives, especially when things get tough. Sometimes we fall into thinking that Hashem has forgotten us, allowing the negative side of darkness to have free rein. When we go through personal difficulties, we may be about falling so low into despair, that we think that everything is lost. Even when still believing that everything is from Hashem, and for the best, we may be prone to think, “It is for the best to punish me for all my multitude sins and shortcomings. I surely deserve that everything will end up in the worst possible way.” We may still think we have great emunah (faith) understanding that emunah is not just the naïve belief that everything will turn out well in the end, as many things don’t really turn out so well in the end. We all know that true emunah is to believe that even when things don’t turn out well, like the Holocaust; it’s still for our best. So we may spiral down into the negative thinking of the worst possible scenario that could happen to us, which of course in our great ‘emunah’ we accept would be for the best. 

Fear of the Evil Eye
Sometimes it may be that due to selfish bragging we open ourselves to the evil eye – (ayin hara). The Talmud quotes Rav proclaiming that “Ninety-nine percent of those buried in the cemetery died as a result of the evil eye, and only one percent died naturally.”[1] However, ayin hara only affects those who believe in it, because if we look at ourselves through Hashem’s eye of kindness we do not leave room for the evil eye to have any power over us. The problem arises when we allow other people’s evil eye to affect us, and we begin to look at ourselves in their negative judgmental light. However, as long as they are unable to affect our positive hopeful attitude towards ourselves, then we do not allow ayin hara to have any effect on us.

G*d’s Unity Transcends the World of Light and Darkness

Negative thoughts of despair are really like idol worship because they empower the sitra acha (the side of impurity) by telling ourselves that the one and only G*d, has hidden His face and allowed evil to take over. This is almost like giving power to a dual Deity, the G*d of goodness and G*d forbid the god of negative darkness and evil eye, etc. The Torah teaches us to believe in One and only G*d, whose unity overrides the world of dichotomy including good and evil, light and darkness, etc. The existence of darkness is only for the sake of illuminating the light which grows brighter through contrast and counterpoint. This is why Israel had to go down to the very darkest most perverse place in the world – Egypt, before we could be redeemed to receive the greatest light of the Torah.[2]

The Effects of Positive Thinking 

So is it not naïve to always believe that everything will turn out good in the end?  Why should I believe in something which may be unrealistic? Positive thinking can affect the final outcome of every situation, according to the saying: “think good and it will become good.”[3] The righteous women in Egypt acted according to this principle when they packed their tambourines. “Miriam the prophetess sister of Aaron took the drum in her hand.”[4] The righteous women of that generation trusted that Hashem would perform a miracle for them, and they therefore brought drums with them from Egypt.[5]  King David writes in his Tehillim, “Hashem is your keeper; Hashem is your shadow upon your right hand.”[6]  Just as the shadow follows the movements of the person, likewise, according to how a person acts below, so is he acted upon from Above. In the same vein when we have mercy towards others, Hashem will have mercy upon us. Therefore, if we are sure that Hashem will provide for all our needs, all our requests will be fulfilled from Above. However, if we are always worried, then the object of our worries will come to pass, G*d forbid.  “Happy is the person who won’t forget You, but places his trust in Hashem, then Hashem will be his shadow.” King David trusted so greatly in Hashem, that he would recite songs of praise to Hashem before the redemption from the many troubles he experienced. Likewise, Israel recited song at the Sea before the actual redemption, as they trusted that Hashem would surely part the Sea for them. When we trust that Hashem will fulfill all our needs, then G*d will fulfill all our needs, for He is our shadow.[7]

Believing in the Best Possible Outcome

True emunah is to believe that things will turn out according to the revealed best possible way, even if it will take a miracle to make that happen, for “is anything too hard for Hashem?”[8]  Our positive thinking will affect the final result both because a positive attitude energetically attracts positive outcomes, and also because our actions are affected by our attitude. If we have a positive outlook, we will act in ways that bring about a positive end result. Our prayer is so much more powerful when we believe that Hashem will answer it for good. However, if in the end, things don’t turn out the way we had hoped, then is the time to have emunah that this too was from Hashem for our own good. Yet, to begin with we must always believe in the very best possible outcome. Even when things look impossible, “Hashem’s salvation is like a blink of an eye.”[9]  

Exodus from Darkness

The Pesach story teaches us to believe in miracles to bring about a happy end. Although we had sunk into the very lowest level of being absorbed within the darkness of Egypt in the 49th gate of impurity, Hashem still took us out with a strong arm[10] full of wondrous miracles, to the 49th gate of purity. The Exodus is called: יסוד היסודות ושורש הכל /yesod hayesodot v’shoresh hakol – “The foundation of the foundations and the root of all.”[11]   Through the revealed miracles of the Exodus we learn to recognize the hidden miracles of everyday life, which are the foundation of the entire Torah.  In order to have a portion in the Torah, we need to believe in everything described in it which is all miracles beyond nature.[12]   

Let us take every opportunity to thank Hashem for His goodness and blessings, and let us strengthen our emunah that for those who are still single the right man is just around the corner, that the barren women will bear fruit, and that we all be strengthened in the belief that the final Geulah (redemption) is at our doorsteps! May our strengthened emunah draw down the Shechina to become our shadow for the ultimate good!

Why Did I Choose to Get Vaccinated Against COVID-19? Part II.

 

Parashat Tzav

In Part I of this article, featured last week, Parashat Vayikra, we discussed the Torah criteria for deciding who is to be trusted in medical issues, since a non-professional reader has no ability to assess the arguments circulating regarding the COVID-19 vaccine. I also shared with you my results when checking the credibility of two Anti-Vaxxers. Furthermore, I compared the number who died from COVID-19 with those who died from the COVID-19 vaccine. Finally, I briefly addressed the question of whether the current pandemic is a hoax invented by ‘Big Pharma.’ Read Part I of this article. I got more comments on my blog and also privately than I could have imagined. I only responded occasionally, due to time constraints, and also because I don’t believe that it is possible to convince the anti-waxers (by the way that word is not meant derogatorily and I certainly didn’t use it to vilify anyone, but only to write more concisely). I do not expect you all to agree with everything I write although I’m happy for comments, but let us keep them on the topic, without making hateful judgments. 

Has the COVID-19 Vaccine Been Properly Tested?

I do understand those who are hesitating to get the COVID-19 vaccine due to it being relatively new, without much time to prove or disprove whether the vaccine could cause long-term side effects, G-d forbid. Yet, considering the devastating pandemic, that has claimed millions of lives worldwide and more than 6,000 lives in Israel alone, it is understandable that the FDA granted emergency validation to Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine, a year after the outbreak of the pandemic. This was only after the vaccine had been going through rigorous phase III clinical trials, tested on more than 30.000 volunteers, and proven safe and efficient by numerous competent experts. In order to be qualified for evaluation by the FDA, the vaccine must first be approved by the DSMB, which is composed of independent experts, who remain anonymous, to prevent pressure from vaccine manufacturers and government officials. Today, more than 14 million people have been vaccinated and monitored. Although common side effects include sore muscles, headaches, and fatigue, these discomforts typically subside after 1-2 days. The COVID-19 vaccines in current use did not show evidence of unexpected serious adverse events. The effectiveness of the Pfizer vaccination is furthermore verified by the fact that thank G-d, Israel sees a 60% drop in hospitalizations for age 60-plus 3 weeks after the 1st shot. The effectiveness of the vaccine is even more evident from the drastic decline of active cases of COVID-19 in Israel from when the immunization of the vaccine kicked in (about 1-3 weeks after receiving the second shot). On Feb 4, three days before the end of the third lockdown in Israel, there were still 80,889 active cases of COVID-19. Despite opening the lockdown on February 7th, the active cases have steadily gone down, and today, March 24, Baruch Hashem we are down to 14,002 active cases on  Worldmeter Israel. Thus, since the vaccination, the active cases declined more than 65,000 cases so far!

Hashem Prepares the Cure Before the Wound 

We have a Talmudic principle, that Hashem always prepares the cure before the wound (Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 13b). More than 30 years ago, the method of mRNA used in Pfizer vaccines today, was developed by a Hungarian female biochemist called Katalin Karikó, based on scientific discoveries launched in 1961. Karikó was an ugly duckling in the academic world, but she persisted in her research, until, together with Drew Weissman, she finally received patents for the mRNA technology in 2012. When mice were injected with this modified mRNA, they lived. Both my mind and heart resonate very much with Karikó, and I believe she is sincere when she says, “I always wanted to help people…That was the motivation for me, and I was always optimistic. But to help that many people, I never imagined that… ”

What do the Rabbis Say? 

It is easy to compose a long list of rabbis who are both for and against anything because the term ‘Rabbi’ is very broad. It ranges from a Cheder rabbi, who teaches 5-year-olds, to a halachic posek, whose authority to render halachic decisions is accepted by hundreds of thousands of Jews. The anti-vaxxer list of supporting rabbis does not include top halachic poskim (halachic authorities). As expected, many of the rabbis opposing the vaccine are Breslev, a group known to shun the use of medicine in general. Rabbinic halachic authority, including those in the forefront of medicine and halacha, concede that receiving the COVID-19 vaccine is a halachic obligation, for the sake of saving lives. The rabbis concur that there is a Torah halachic obligation for an individual Jew to expose himself to a minimal future danger, in order to save someone else from a greater present danger. There is a halachic consensus that this is the quality of righteousness (Rashi, T. (2018). When the Arrow Came before the Trolley: Jewish Perspectives on the Trolley Dilemma. Philosophia, 46, 193–206). This halachic principle is explained well by Rav Asher Weiss, Rosh Kollel, Av Beit Din, and the posek for Shaarei Zedek hospital, responsible for answering weighty questions that require a blend of Torah erudition, a background in medical knowledge, and sensitivity to the issues involved. Another well-known Rabbi and Israel Prize laureate, who adheres to this halachic principle is Rabbi Professor Avraham Steinberg, who serves as Director of the Medical Ethics Unit & Chairman, IRB Committee, and is Senior Child Neurologist at Shaare Zedek Hospital; Chief Editor of the 27 volume Head of the Talmudic Encyclopedia, and author of the Encyclopedia of Jewish Medical Ethics. I am not attempting to supply a comprehensive list, but it includes Rabbis Chaim Kanievsky, Gershon Edelstein and Shalom Cohen, and many other highly respected Rabbis in the world of halacha. Also, the Biala Rabbi, Rabbi Ben Tzion Rabbinowitzthe late Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, believed in the importance of vaccines. “For preventive medicine to be most successful and effective, it is necessary to start it from earliest childhood—beginning with vaccination…” There is virtually no dispute among contemporary rabbinic authorities (including Chareidi rabbis) regarding the halachic position justifying vaccination. Therefore, the reasons that some Chareidi communities apparently advocate vaccine hesitancy and skepticism are simply not rooted in any halachic approach… (Jewish Ethics Regarding Vaccination, Tsuriel Rashi, The Moskowitz School of Communication, Ariel University). 

Torah Sources on Vaccinations 

The Rabbis’ ruling, mandating COVID-19 vaccination, is based on Torah sources and the rulings of the Rabbinic authorities that preceded them. Commenting on the Torah verse, “Beware for yourself; and guard your soul and body” (Devarim 4:9), the Rambam writes, “It is a positive mitzvah to remove any obstacle that could pose a danger to life, and to be very careful regarding these matters. If a person leaves a dangerous obstacle and does not remove it, he negates the observance of a positive commandment, and violates the negative commandment: Do not cause blood to be spilled. Our Sages forbade many matters because they involve a threat to life. Whenever a person transgresses these guidelines, saying: I will risk my life, what does this matter to others, or I am not careful about these things, he should be punished by stripes for rebelliousness” (Rambam, Laws of Murder and the Preservation of Life 11:4-5). This principle, which prevents life-threatening danger is reflected in the Shulchan Aruch: “For any matter that threatens human life, there is a positive commandment to remove it and to guard against it and to be very careful about the matter, as is written, “beware and guard your soul” (Devarim 4:9). If a person does not remove it but leaves the matter resulting in danger, he nullifies a positive mitzvah and transgresses [the negative mitzvah] “you shall not cause blood [to be spilled]” (Devarim 22:8). Anyone who transgresses one of these things and related items, and says, ‘Behold I endanger myself and others,’ or ‘I am not careful in this,’ [the Court] gives him lashes for rebellion, yet, those who guard themselves against these will receive good blessings” (Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpat 427:8,10). 

On this background, Dr. Edward Jenner’s development of the first vaccine for smallpox, in 1796 was welcomed in the Jewish world. The leading 19th-century sage,  Rabbi Yisrael Lifschitz (1782–1860, Danzig) wrote, “…the righteous Jenner, who has invented this vaccine, is certainly one of the righteous among the Nations and will be rewarded in the next world for having saved thousands and tens of thousands from illness, death and the plague” (Tiferes Yisrael, Pirkei Avot 3:14). Even in the past, when vaccination was much more dangerous than today, the halachic authorities recommended them: “Although, there may be a certain danger caused by the vaccination, and some died through vaccination since the danger of avoiding the vaccination is so much greater, one is obligated to become vaccinated” (Tiferes Yisrael, Yoma 8:3). Avraham Hamburg collected several halachic responsa of the Rabbis of his time who answered unanimously that one must get vaccinated. This was despite the fact that in their time, some people would indeed die from the vaccine (Abraham ben Solomon, Aleh Terufah [Leaf of Healing],1785). “In (the previous generation), praise be to Hashem, we had expert physicians, who produced safe vaccines, which are used daily (Zivchei Tzedek). And now, physicians have become wiser, making an injection with a needle in the arm of the children, whereby, the children do not contract smallpox” (Rabbi Chaim Falagi, 1786-1868, Turkey, Kaf Hachayim, Yoreh Deah 116:60). 

What Convinced me to Get Vaccinated 

When I heard COVID-19 Vaccine in Halacha A Shiur By HaRav Asher Weiss Shlit"a,

I was extremely touched, not only by the Rabbi’s Torah erudition and the logical sequence of the many halachic sources that he quoted but by his caring, loving attitude. He spoke about feeling the pain of others and caring to do everything in our power to diminish their falling ill and suffering. “People are dying, people are suffering, but we can alleviate this awful pain, and diminish the suffering and save many people…” With these words, Rav Asher Weiss lifted me out of my selfishness, which I had, unfortunately, absorbed from my surroundings, thinking, “why should I, a healthy individual, risk bringing toxins into my system, when, most likely, I would survive, if G-d forbid, I was to contract COVID-19. Rabbi Weiss reminded me that we should care not only about ourselves. Rather, we need to feel the pain of others. People are suffering and dying by the millions, but if we are willing to do a small sacrifice, entailed by the risk of taking the relatively safe vaccine, we have the ability to end the pandemic. The Torah teaches us to care for the general community and mandates that we take a small risk, even to our own lives, in order to save many more lives in the long run. This caring attitude was a jarring contrast with what Sherri Tenpenny uttered: “I told all my family that if you get the vaccine, I will not take care of you when you get sick, I will not shop or cook for you or support you in any way.” This statement is diametrically opposed to the Torah outlook and halacha. For example, even when a person caused his own dangerous illness, we are still obligated to break Shabbat to take care of him or her (Rabbi Asher Weiss, The Laws of Healing on Shabbat and Yom Kippur pg. 28). The anti-vaxxers condemn the doctors, the medical system, and the government as being one big conspiracy, claiming that they will purposely try to kill us with their vaccine, whereas the inventors of the COVID-19 vaccine and the rabbis who advocate it, emphasize the importance of saving lives. When King Solomon decided the dispute between the two women, both claiming to be the mother of the same baby, he noticed that one claimed, “her baby is dead!” whereas, the other emphasized, “my baby is alive”. The wisest of all men then knew, without a shadow of a doubt, that the one who emphasized life spoke the truth (Malbim I Melachim 3:22). 

Some Recommended Relevant Articles and Videos of Halachic Approaches to Vaccine and more:
https://revivimen.yhb.org.il/2021/01/01/vaccination-against-the-corona-virus/
https://traditiononline.org/halakha-approaches-the-covid-19-vaccine/#easy-footnote-bottom-4-13392
https://www.yutorah.org/download.cfm?materialID=550132
https://www.chabad.org/therebbe/letters/default_cdo/aid/2185973/jewish/Vaccination-and-To
https://academic.oup.com/phe/article/13/2/215/5877016?searchresult=1
https://www.thelehrhaus.com/commentary/vaccines-hysteria-and-rabbinic-responsibility-a-plea-from-the-trenches/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvdRqMiPfL4...
https://www.timesofisrael.com/top-ultra-orthodox-rabbis-recommend-community-vaccinate-against-covid-19/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/orthodox-rabbis-in-us-israel-tell-followers-to-vaccinate-but-will-they-listen/
https://www.thelakewoodscoop.com/news/2020/12/forgery-harav-shmuel-kamenetzky-disputes-individuals-who-falsely-claimed-his-endorsement-against-covid-vaccine.html
https://5townscentral.com/2020/12/14/rav-shmuel-kamenetsky-responds-to-a-false-letter-in-his-name-regarding-covid-vaccine/
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/wellness-qanon-coronavirus/
https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2018-25841-001

Why Did I Choose to Get Vaccinated Against COVID-19? Part I.

 

Parashat Vayikra

Although I don’t consider myself extreme, I’ve been seriously health conscious most of my life.  Yet, I’m certainly moderate compared to some of my raw-food dietitian mentors, such as Shoshanna Harrari, but that, of course, is all relative. I try to eat organic, for the most part. I will never consume inorganic grapes or strawberries since they are especially heavily sprayed with poisonous pesticides. The other day, my husband bought me a fresh-squeezed juice at a juice bar in the Yehuda Market of Jerusalem. However, since it included strawberry juice, I wouldn’t touch it. So, he gave the Nis-20 juice away to a passerby. I also avoid medicine like the plague. I don’t recall ever having taken as much as an aspirin. My medicine cabinet includes valerian, passionflower, sage, elderberries, and thyme. I laugh, when my husband, the doctor, tells me about new medical research, proving the benefits of various herbs, that we in the herbal community knew about all along. 

Why am I telling you all this? Being an environmentalist, who lives a holistic life, would naturally place me in the anti-vaccine camp, but I am not a conformer to any kind of herd mentality. I try to remain not only an independent thinker, but I also follow my heart and my inner intuition. Having to make a decision about the COVID-19 vaccination came upon me suddenly and unexpectedly. Less than three months after I first realized the choice before me, I find myself one of the 6% of Bat Ayin residents, who have received two vaccination doses. It’s already been a while after the second dose, and despite the horror stories told on the web, we, Baruch Hashem, still remain alive to tell the story. 

So, I will try to share with you here, why, despite being a person who avoids modern medicine as much as possible, I decided to get vaccinated against COVID-19. This, notwithstanding the sea of anti-Vaxxer warning YouTubes, I’ve been flooded with by my herbal community. Since there is so much to say, and you may not have time to read to the end, I will encapsulate here the main decisive factor that convinced me to make the sacrifice and take the risk of the vaccination. The main Torah principle I live by is: that no matter what, saving lives overrides everything else. To save lives, we are even permitted to break the holy Shabbat, so surely, we must be willing to take future health risks for the sake of saving current lives. 

What is the Torah Criteria for Deciding Who to Trust When Truth is Absent 

One of the signs of the forthcoming redemption is ‘conflicting information overload.’ It is becoming more and more difficult to tell truth from lies, as it states, “In the times of the approach of Mashiach, impudence will increase… and truth will become absent” (Babylonian Talmud, Sotah 49b). This notion explains why so many people today are being misinformed about the COVID-19 vaccines. Not being a scientist, I’m unqualified to investigate the biochemical operations of the various vaccines available and decipher the real truth about vaccines, as Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, one of the greatest current Zionist halachic authorities in Israel, writes: “There is no point in reading articles refuting the vaccine because a non-professional reader has no ability to assess the arguments and check the data…” Yet, having received a solid Torah foundation helped me decide whom to trust. Jewish law mandates trusting medical experts on medical issues. For example, on Yom Kippur, a sick person must be fed according to the decision of a medical expert (Mishna Yoma 82a). Even when the patient himself doesn’t want to eat, but a physician – even a non-Jew – says that he has to eat, the patient must be given food as directed by the doctor, provided he is a מוּמְחֶה/mumche – ‘expert’ (Shulchan Aruch Harav 618:2). What is the halachic criterion for determining who is an ‘expert’? Simply, an expert is someone endorsed by other experts. A medical expert is a well-known specialist in his field or someone who has published scientific articles, that are endorsed and cited by other medical experts. The Torah instructs us that in matters of medicine, we must act in accordance with the majority of doctors. The vast majority of doctors, who are experts in maintaining health, hold that it is very important to be vaccinated. Therefore, it is a mitzvah to listen to them (Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, Vaccination against the Corona Virus, January 1, 2021). I resonate with Rabbi Eliezer Melamed’s attitude, to give leeway to doctors and specialists, who oppose the vaccine, to prove their point. “It would be valuable if they delved into their research and attempted to prove their position – perhaps they could benefit the entire world… In any case, the ones who need to determine whether the claims of those who oppose the vaccine are convincing, are the majority of experts in the field of medicine” (Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, Ibid.). Today, through social media, any charismatic charlatan can say whatever he feels like to thousands of people through his YouTube channel. But, why should I believe him or her? What is the reliability of such and such so-called expert? Who endorsed them and their ‘scientific’ articles? 

Checking the Credibility of Some Anti-Vaxxers  

Actually, the multitude of Anti-Vaxxer messages I receive, are mainly YouTube broadcasts, rather than published scientific articles. I didn’t find any of their scientific articles published in reputable medical journals. Their names do not appear in accepted medical platforms such as PubMed; MedScape; WebMD; WHO; American Medical Association etc. To this, you may respond that these are all agents of the accepted medical establishment, who work for ‘Big Pharma’ and are part of the conspiracy to control humanity. I can only answer, that the consensus among past and present halachic authorities, is that these are the medical experts that must be relied upon in medical issues. In addition, I personally know many physicians, who could be considered part of the so-called ‘conspiracy,’ and I can tell you, that none of them have yet grown horns.

On the other hand, the ‘conspiracy believers’ do not get such good reviews to their credit. For example, Sherri Tenpenny is an American osteopath and anti-vaccination activist, who supports the disproved hypothesis that vaccines cause autism. She is the author of four books, opposing vaccination. Her 2015 lecture tour of Australia was canceled due to a public outcry over her views on vaccination, which go against the established scientific consensus. Dr. Tenpenny’s opinions, while disproved by science and criticized by medical experts, are not against the law and should be allowed a forum.  (Anti-vaccination views are misguided - but not illegal. Sydney Morning-Herald. 11 January 2015). 

V. A. Shiva Ayyadurai (born Vellayappa Ayyadurai Shiva, is an engineer, politician, entrepreneur, and promoter of conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, and unfounded medical claims (Breland, Ali. Wellness Influencers are Spreading Qanon Conspiracies About the Coronavirus). Ayyadurai makes the widely disputed claim to have invented email (Kolawole Emi, February 17, 2012). Similar disapproval has been given to most of the other sources sent to me, by well-meaning friends, from my wellness community. A comprehensive listing is beyond the scope of this article.  

Comparing Numbers of Who Died from What 

Responding to all the anti-Vaxxer claims, I’ve heard and read, could fill several books. Therefore, I’m just choosing to discuss a few claims, concerning which I just cannot remain silent. I was shocked by what I heard on Sherri Tenpenny’s YouTube warning, against the danger of the COVID-19 vaccine. Who is she to make a prophecy of doom that everyone who gets the vaccine will die within a year? This kind of scare-technique goes against all medical ethics and certainly has not been verified. The Phase 3 clinical trial of BNT162b2 began on July 27 and enrolled 43,661 participants.  As of November 13, 2020, 41,135  have received a second dose of the vaccine. This is more than four months ago when according to Tenpenny they were already supposed to have experienced the severe fatal symptoms. Tenpenny’s claim, that an outrageous number of ‘vaccine victims’ who already ‘died’ of anaphylactic shock immediately after receiving the vaccine, is also completely incorrect. Out of 13,794,904 people who received the vaccine, a total of 113 deaths were reported to VAERS, 65% of which were among LTCF [Long-term Care Facilities] residents. This is a death rate of 0.00081914 % of those vaccinated. Compare this number with the  3% death rate of those infected with COVID-19 globally! That’s more than a 10.000% higher mortality! There seems to be a double standard among the Anti-Vaxxers. Regarding those who died after receiving the vaccine, they maintain that the vaccine caused their death, but concerning those who died of COVID-19 it is claimed: “The number of deaths that have actually been caused by COVID-19 is entirely speculative. There have been countless reports from all over the world that hospitals have been listing COVID as the cause of death, even when patients died of entirely unrelated causes…” 

Is the Current Pandemic Invented by Big Pharma? 

Time and again, I had to listen to people claiming that there is no pandemic! “Whistleblowers have reported being instructed to list COVID as the cause of death if even a tiny, harmless trace of the virus was found in the body.” Oh, come on! Do I really have to document that hospitals the world over are filled to the brim with Corona patients, and many have been running out of drugs, beds and ventilators? How can anyone claim that there is no pandemic when more than 2½ million people have passed away of COVID-19? Who doesn’t know someone who has succumbed to this terrible plague? To those who claim that although Rabbi, Dr. Avraham Twerski died from Corona at the age of 90, he was old and would have died anyway, I will counter, that without COVID-19, He may possibly have lived another year or even decade, granting the world another brilliant book or even ten! 

Stay tuned for Part II of this article, which will be featured next week, Parashat Tzav. It will discuss the following topics: Has the COVID-19 vaccine been properly tested? What do the Rabbis Say? Torah Sources on vaccinations, and finally I will share what personally convinced me to get vaccinated.